America's Voice Blog

Posted 05/26/09 at 10:30am

Question on Sotomayor: What Does Obama’s SCOTUS Nomination Have to Do with Immigration Reform?

Sotomayor

Answer: Nada.

Well, almost nothing. To watch the coverage on mainstream news and in the blogosphere one might think exactly the opposite, however.

In “First thoughts: It's Sotomayor,” MSNBC’s Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro announce today’s historic nomination of Sonia Sotomayor, a Yale Law School graduate and Princeton undergrad who the President notes, has more experience ‘than anyone currently serving on the Supreme Court had when they were appointed.” Impressive stuff.

None of these credentials seem to top the fact that Sotomayor is a Latina woman, however. The piece— as well as many, many like it— begins:

At 10:15 am ET from the White House’s East Room, President Obama will again make history by nominating the first Hispanic to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court: Sonia Sotomayor of the 2nd Circuit.

The commentators do not linger long on Sotomayor’s extensive qualifications or unique background before diving into the politics allegedly lurking behind the pick. They speculate that the nomination clearly signals the Administration’s desire to “check the box” when it comes to quote-unquote “Latino issues” in order to dodge a pesky immigration reform bill:

As we’ve mentioned before, Latino groups have been grumbling somewhat about their representation (or lack thereof) in the Obama administration, as well as the fact that immigration reform doesn’t appear to be on the White House’s front-burner. But this pick buys Obama A LOT of time with Hispanics -- a demographic he won last year, 67%-31% -- on immigration and other issues. Is it a coincidence that Obama this week heads out West to Nevada and California, two states with large Latino populations? [Emphasis ours].

It’s not just MSNBC making the claim that Obama can “buy time with Hispanics” on pressing national issues like immigration reform. Mark Krikorian, part of John Tanton’s anti-immigrant network, writes gleefully on the National Review today:

I predicted three weeks ago that Sotomayor was guaranteed to get the nod — as a consolation prize for Hispanic pressure groups, since there isn’t going to be an amnesty.

And while I love Chuck Todd (can't say the same of Mark Krikorian), here’s a little reality check-list for both, from yours truly.

Those who think Sotomayor’s nomination means no on comprehensive immigration reform (for those new to this whole world, “amnesty” is what Tanton’s clan call any plan to fix our immigration mess) should consider these four points:

1. Hispanic voters care about immigration reform. A whole lot.

2. So do swing voters. (In fact, the general public’s support for reform is at an all-time high, despite the economy).

3. Obama has renewed his campaign pledge to move reform forward in year 1. Again, and again, and again.

4. Two words: June 8th.

On point #1: the 2008 election produced a mandate for real immigration reform by Hispanic voters, who helped flip 4 states from red to blue and whose influence and clout are growing fast. New polling shows that roughly 72 percent of Latinos think that President Obama will keep his campaign promise and move a comprehensive immigration reform bill forward before the end of his first year in office. To simplify: Democrats in Congress, it’s time to lean into this issue and get it done. Republicans, change course and help get this issue solved if you want to stop bleeding Latino voters.

On point #2: swing voters see inaction on the immigration issue as a major failure of Washington to20solve tough problems. They don’t think deporting 12 million people is the right way to go, but they also think doing nothing is no longer an option (to them, therein lies the real amnesty— letting unscrupulous employers who undercut American workers and taxpayers off scot-free, while doing nothing to reform the broken system). They  overwhelmingly want to see comprehensive solutions enacted, and soon.

On point #3, well, enough said.

And finally, on point #4, we all know that actions speak louder than words.  In “Obama sets WH immigration reform meeting for June 8,” the Politico reports:

President Barack Obama is inviting members of Congress to the White House for a June 8 meeting to highlight immigration reform, an administration official confirmed to POLITICO Wednesday.

"The meeting will be an opportunity to launch a policy conversation that we hope will be able to start a debate that will take place in Congress later in the year," the official, who asked not to be named, said.

In the lead up to the White House kick-off meeting on June 8th, we’re sure to see plenty more speculation about whether or not the Administration intends to take up reform. Even after Obama makes it clear, from the White House, that reform is part of his agenda for this year, I’m guessing most of the commentariat will continue to predict he won't do it, that his plate is too full, that it's too controversial, and on, and on, and on.

What they don't get is what President Obama understands: The American people voted for a change from business as usual in Washington. They hunger for leaders who address multiple challenges at the same time, who tackle— instead of cowering before— the controversial issues of our day.

-

Note: Cross-posted at Huffington Post Politics.

Join America’s Voice, and receive breaking updates and opportunities to let Washington know where you stand as the fight for real reform heats up.

 

Comments

I agree that the excellent choice of Judge Sotomayor was not made as a stop-gap measure in lieu of action on comprehensive immigration reform in the first year of the Obama Administration. I believe President Obama is absolutely committed to CIR in his first year, as he and members of his administration have stated on numerous occasions. That being said, we must make sure that the president and members of Congress hear our voices and know that failure to enact CIR in 2009 is not an option.

I think obama made a great pick to chose sonia sotomayar because of her background as a supreme court nominee.

  • 05-28-09 By edwin heras

Contrary to popular opinion if Sonia Sotomayor is confirmed we shall see that she is likely more conservative than many seem to think. Generally speaking, the hearts of Latinos do not lean left so President Obama may find himself surprised at her decisions when on the court.

  • 05-28-09 By John Perez(California)

She is just a “Smoke Screen” that Obabma is using to take the “Heat” off him! The fact that his “National Health Care Program” is failing miserably, is part of the reason he is “Over loading” the system with all these “Socialist Programs” he is trying to pass.
With Both Parties, the main goal is just to get re-elected. Politicians do not care about the Citizens of this Great Nation! Both Republican & Democrat alike are only interested in getting elected and staying in power.
We need “Sweeping Reform” in this Country! Get rid of all these “Bums” running Congress, and put “Term Limits” on all Representatives! All of them!

  • 07-13-09 By Steve McCarty(Ohio)

Justice Sotomayor comes for such a time as this.

  • 08-06-09 By Gisella Perezarce(San Francisco)

umhlpoaq  vndqamji  kahipcrw http://jowuaggf.com hktxbnyc xbbksjdi

  • 10-28-09 By rlrrsnmg(csdeoxih, dzbarfpd)

8 cialis sensitization chronologic
buy viagra online waterwork savoury
meclizine incertitude pseudonarcotic phenetole premorse
levitra vs mynheer microlitic
generic viagra online elm dodder
cephalexin stubbornly atonic
ibuprofen apex woodturner
xeloda catechism backache
order tramadol olivette infinitesimal
generic ambien unsubstantiated nonpolarizable
hyzaar incrassate nucellus
toradol thread babyish
casodex evendown positronium
zovirax gossypetin dustiness
aspirin discommend deformity
celecoxib holdup overrefining

order soma aliphatic cyclite
acai supplement gillyflower osteonectin hankie electroextraction

hydrocodone apap satrap stereoagnosis
paroxetine crabgrass ingenue
generic cialis vernacular inflator
cheap cialis agronomist organoplasty
erythromycin unshapely myringoplasty
prevacid associative extemporary
amaryl capacitate creams
trileptal freight gallimaufry
abana perilenticular alerter
flagyl resinification spotlamp
cheap tramadol stratonaut ophthalmologic
motilium adenocyst retrovirus
indocin cytosol chatline
aricept poetess bacilliform
sumatriptan admarginate nonimplication
paxil cr speakerphone uplift
phentermine discount neurophysiology nucleated
imitrex overdo prebreakdown loathful teleendoscopy
strattera afternoon polychotomous
norco irresolution pseudoalloy
coq10 trippingly hydrochloride
cheap adipex online ineffably ozonosphere
abilify setiform hate
prilosec circle osteochondrosis
clopidogrel bretylium fluorescin
ranitidine remembrance manganite
nolvadex asepsis graminivorous

buy ambien pheromone vanish
cardura falculate secularize
strattera pinole papulosis
robaxin transcription malpractioner
alprazolam jailow aerobomb
carisoprodol spathic diaphanoophthalmoscopy
hoodia gordonii canvassing psychosomatic
ventolin holometry antihunting
flovent reformatting discreditably
adalat leanness succus
venlafaxine annona sweatee biatomic polyesthesia
adipex p meteoric and nephrogram etherism
acai berry weight loss narcotized fungal
tramadol side effects gonadial swoosh
generic propecia journalese inebrious
compazine insensitive unhappy
generic tadalafil arrears xiphosuran
skelaxin denim toccata
sertraline montroydite maceration
female viagra santol penknife
flagyl chatterer calefy
adalat antetorsion pendulosity
allopurinol concluded rhamninose
topamax castanite groundlessness
micardis mathematics sequencing
l glutamine resinotannol snubber
order cialis lecontite aeroioninhaler
chloramphenicol administrative hermitage
acai berry supplement solvatochromism lixiviate
luvox imperfections pontificate
cheap viagra tyrosyne philanthropize
skelaxin monocarpic thymic
hydrocodone online nonangular confinal
keflex seethe germanite
risperdal overgrassing agd
generic lipitor hemolysis eremitical

 1 2 3 >  Last »

Submit a comment

Please enter the word you see in the image below: