Republicans Reflect on Latino Voter Loss, Immigration, and Red Meat

America's Voice Blog

Posted 11/11/08 at 03:37pm

As the pundits move away from discussing how Latinos turned out in favor of Democrats at historic levels in 2008 to analyzing why this shift occurred, Republican analysts are chiming in: the GOP encouraged the kind of "red-meat" xenophobia within its ranks that blocked immigration reform. And it backfired, bigtime.

Washington Post writer Eugene Robinson, in a column highlighting why Republicans must shift directions to stay viable electorally, stated:

"Here's the truly ominous trend for the Republicans: Hispanic voters nationwide chose Obama over McCain by 67 percent to 31 percent. This is a huge shift from 2004, when George Bush won an estimated 44 percent of the Hispanic vote, and the trend was instrumental in moving states such as Florida, Nevada and Colorado into the Democratic column last Tuesday. How did the Republicans manage this feat? By blocking sensible immigration reform and appealing to the red-meat conservative base with rhetoric that could only be taken as xenophobic. Hispanics constitute the nation's biggest and fastest-growing minority. Apparently they have no place in the "center-right America" of Republican fantasy."

The Latino vote comprised 9% of the electorate nationwide in 2008, a figure that totals over 11 million voters. This turnout represents a jump of over 3 million voters since 2004, when 7.6 million Latinos cast ballots, and is approximately double the Latino turnout of 2000. Ominously for Republicans, the Latino vote broke overwhelmingly Democratic in 2008. After supporting Democratic candidate John Kerry by a 56-44% margin against George W. Bush in 2004, Latinos gave Democratic candidate Barack Obama their support at a 67-31% margin against John McCain. As the New York Times showed, Latinos' movement towards Democrats was one of the biggest demographic shifts from 2004 to 2008.

As Latino polling expert Sergio Bendixen stated:

"The debate over immigration started driving Hispanic voters toward the Democratic party, and the economic black hole clinched it."

A prominent Republican, Senator Mel Martinez (R-FL), stated on NBC's "Meet the Press":

"The very divisive rhetoric of the immigration debate set a very bad tone for our brand as Republicans...there were voices within our party, frankly, which if they continue with that kind of rhetoric, anti-Hispanic rhetoric, that so much of it was heard, we're going to be relegated to minority status."

To top it off, William McKenzie, editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, examined the subset of the Latino Evangelical vote and concluded:

"It's safe to say enough Latino evangelicals marched away from the GOP to matter in states such as Florida and Colorado. Barack Obama won there after George W. Bush prevailed in 2004." McKenzie quoted prominent Latino Evangelical leader, Rev. Samuel Rodriguez, who said "Immigration, and immigration only, cost Republicans. The Pat Buchanans drove Latino evangelicals away with scary rhetoric about immigration during Congress' recent debates on the subject." McKenzie concluded his column by stating, "the GOP can't keep narrowing itself, forcing out minority voters. The party either expands or shrinks into irrelevancy."

But the clincher is, it wasn't just the Latino electorate who voted in favor of common sense and humane immigration policies. Many non-Latino voters refused to support leading anti-immigrant crusaders such as Marilyn Musgrave (CO-4), Thelma Drake (VA-02), Lou Barletta (running for Rep. Kanjorski's seat in PA-11), and Virgil Goode (VA-5) and, in many other close races across the country, supported candidates with more comprehensive approaches to immigration reform.

The Republican Party is at a cross-roads. Either it cuts out the red-meat xenophobia and gets on the right side of the immigration issue, or it stands in danger of being relegated to "minority status" (a fairly ironic term, all things considered) for the foreseeable future.

By Paco Fabian
Permalink
Send to a friend
Comments

Comments

Very interesting. Thanks for the information.

Jim
<a >contra costa county divorce mediation</a>

04-07-09 By Jim Jones

McKenzie concluded his column by stating, “the GOP can’t keep narrowing itself, forcing out minority voters. The party either expands or shrinks into irrelevancy.

<a >Dissertation Methodology</a> | <a >Dissertation Help</a> | <a >Term Papers For Sale</a>

05-27-09 By William Gibson(Dallas)

Hey. The truth does not change according to our ability to stomach it. Help me! I can not find sites on the: Side effects of lamisil. I found only this - <a >better than Lamisil</a>. The tablets may, rarely, cause hepatotoxicity, so patients are warned of this and. Be monitored with liver function tests. Use generic lamisil to treat fungus infections and you can buy lamisil from canada pharmacy windows live generic lamisil comes in just one strength. Waiting for a reply :o, Lavey from Liberia.

06-21-09 By Lavey(Liberia)

The significant rise in the margin (as compared to the 2004 elections) is probably due to the ongoing issues on developments of immigration laws. How much these will progress will depend on the current administration’s policies on illegal immigration.

06-23-09 By Permanent Residency Australia

Hello everyone. I never think of the future - it comes soon enough. Help me! It has to find sites on the: Discount cialis. I found only this - <a >quick ship Cialis</a>. Generic cialis, buy cheap generic cialis, tadalafil no prescription. Very few are getting the help they need in dealing with this devastating problem. Thank you very much :eek:. Gemma from Salvador.

06-24-09 By Gemma(Salvador)

Badly need your help. Hello. I`m glad that I found this site. greetings. Help me! Need information about: Mixing cialis and marijuana. I found only this - <a >female Cialis</a>. Cialis dosages every mystery loves the smile. Viagra cialis levitra buy viagra every library who sees that a correspondence a saint who knows the viagra cialis levitra buy viagra stares at every want. Waiting for a reply :eek:, Gabe from Greece.

06-25-09 By Gabe(Greece)

How are you. Read over your compositions, and wherever you meet with a passage which you think is particularly fine, strike it out. Help me! Help to find sites on the: Side effects prograf. I found only this - <a >immunosuppression prograf</a>. Learn about the magic of magicomm and how are powerful cross media solutions can help your business. Free online library - astellas pharma immunosuppressant prograf now available in europe. Waiting for a reply :-(, Baris from Grenada.

06-27-09 By Baris(Grenada)

One year ago yesterday, nearly four hundred immigrant workers were corralled into the National Cattle Congress in Waterloo, Iowa as a part of the now-infamous