America's Voice Blog

Posted 05/13/09 at 01:22pm

Postville Immigration Raid Blog Roundup: Lessons, A Year Later

Church bells

One year ago yesterday, nearly four hundred immigrant workers were corralled into the National Cattle Congress in Waterloo, Iowa as a part of the now-infamous immigration raid in Postville, Iowa.

The Postville raid was one of the most extreme examples of the misplaced priorities of the Bush Administration when it comes to immigration enforcement, where the prosecution of immigrant workers was prioritized over the enforcement of labor standards and other criminal and civil violations committed by plant managers and owners.

Lynda Waddinton, of the Iowa Independent, covered the story of those who marked the anniversary of the raid with red ribbons and the ringing of church bells yesterday in a post titled, “Remembrance organizers seek to prevent another Postville:”

A year ago today, Sister Mary McCauley, pastoral administrator for the region that includes St. Bridget’s Catholic Church in Postville, was greeted by a parishioner with the following words: “Sister, a terrible thing has happened to our town.”

At the time, according to McCauley, she didn’t fully appreciate how true the parishioner’s words would turn out to be. “A terrible thing did happen to the town of Postville. A terrible thing has happened to our Hispanic brothers and sisters. And I add that a terrible thing has happened to our country,” McCauley said by phone on Monday. […]

The “Day of Remembrance” in Postville began at 10 a.m. — the time the immigration raid began — with the ringing of church bells and the blowing of the shofar, a Jewish horn. Bells toll 389 times at St. Paul Lutheran Church in Postville, once for each worker detained in the raid.

The Wall Street Journal, Associated Press, Des Moines Register (here, here, here, and here), Waterloo Courier, and Dallas Morning News also reported on Postville and the Day of Remembrance events across the country­­.

Here are just a few of the reactions from the blogosphere:

ImmigrationProf Blog: Postville One Year Later
"No community should have to go through what Postville has had to go through in the past year," said Maryn Olson, a community activist. […]  Also, people around the country who can't make it to Postville intend to hold services showing their solidarity, she said. "Postville and what happened here have become a rallying point."

Standing FIRM: Today Marks One Year since Postville
The town still suffers and some of the immigrants arrested that day are still caught in the limbo of the broken system. So today, in solidarity with Postville, I’m choosing to ACT in the belief that it is up to us to create the change we want. You can too.

  1. Call your Representative or Congressman and tell them that you support Comprehensive Immigration Reform.

  2. Attend a Remembrance Vigil in your area – for a map of vigils click here.

  3. Don a Red Ribbon in solidarity with the Postville community.

Sojo.net: Postcard from Postville: A Year After the Raids
Postville profoundly changed how we look at the problem of immigration in our country, and it became a symbol of a broken system and human suffering. Christians for Comprehensive Immigration Reform first covered the story of the faith community’s rapid response last May and have returned to Postville this week to continue telling the stories of horror, heroism, and hope.

Inspired Faith, Effective Action: A day of solidarity with Postville and communities affected by immigration raids
Today marks the one year anniversary of the raid in Postville, Iowa, where 389 people were arrested. In Postville and in communities across the country, people are standing in solidarity with immigrant workers and families and their friends and loved ones by calling for justice and comprehensive immigration reform.

Post-Postville: It's About Worker Exploitation, not ICE | IMAGINE 2050
Had ICE been smart a year ago today, it would have claimed—with credibility—that it raided the Postville, Iowa Agriprocessors plant in order to save the workers it seized that infamous day. Postville and the 2008 ICE raid is not simply the story of failed immigration policy; it is the story of years of indifference to the exploitation of the nation’s low-wage workforce.

Immigration - Change.org: Postville Remembered
The most damning account of the Postville debacle is still Erik Camayd-Freixas's (pdf) inside view--as a federal interpreter during the proceedings, he could not keep silent after what he saw. The legal theory behind the Postville prosecutions has been rejected by a unanimous Supreme Court.  Some of us have wondered whether such dubious prosecutions should be rewarded with promotions.

Immigration Impact: Immigration Inching Towards Reform One Year After Postville Raids
One year later, the immigration raid has left Postville nearly insolvent.  Agriprocessers has filed for bankruptcy, Postville’s population has declined by half, and its mayor has resigned because he felt overwhelmed by the town’s problems.
Some progress, however, has been made. Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled that federal identity-theft law can not be applied against many undocumented workers who use false Social Security numbers to work in the U.S.—which thwarts ICE’s efforts to threaten undocumented workers to agree to immediate deportation or boost prison sentences through identity theft charges. And the Obama administration recently issued enforcement guidelines to target bad seed employers instead of focusing on undocumented workers—a step in the right direction. Yet more serious changes are still needed.

AlterNet: One Year After Devastating Immigration Raid: the Time for Reform Has Come
The raid's human cost - devastation for many workers and their families and the negative effect on Postville's economy - was much too high for its perceived benefits. In fact, one of the raid's only real benefits was to shine a light on our country's broken immigration system and the urgent need to fix it.

While Postville stands as a testament to the brokenness of our immigration system, we also have it within our grasp to move real immigration reform forward this year in a way that improves the situation of American families, communities, and workplaces across the country. 

We must learn from what happened in Postville, Iowa, and never allow it to happen again.

Comments

All your given links are very useful these are interesting. I enjoy this post very much.

As the pundits move away from discussing how Latinos turned out in favor of Democrats at historic levels in 2008 to analyzing why this shift occurred, Republican analysts are chiming in: the GOP encouraged the kind of “red-meat” xenophobia within its ranks that blocked immigration reform. And it backfired, bigtime.

The Latino vote comprised 9% of the electorate nationwide in 2008, a figure that totals over 11 million voters. This turnout represents a jump of over 3 million voters since 2004, when 7.6 million Latinos cast ballots, and is approximately double the Latino turnout of 2000.

Latinos’ movement towards Democrats was one of the biggest demographic shifts from 2004 to 2008.

The Latino vote comprised 9% of the electorate nationwide in 2008, a figure that totals over 11 million voters. This turnout represents a jump of over 3 million voters since 2004, when 7.6 million Latinos cast ballots, and is approximately double the Latino turnout of 2000. Ominously for Republicans, the Latino vote broke overwhelmingly Democratic in 2008.

Apparently they have no place in the “center-right America” of Republican fantasy.”

It is a great idea to go after the employers instead of the immigrant employees since the cost of disruption to these communities is too great.

i like this

It is interesting this point of view. Maybe we learn something from this article.

this isnt about illegal workers…its about animal cruelty…mr friedman proud of his biggest kosher plant in the world?...well he and his canada has the biggest baby seal hunt going on right now too…50,000 baby seals clubbed to death…there are numerous violations caught on tape by the news helicopter of this baby seal hunt…what makes one think that he wont have violations in his new plant?...what does kosher have to do with clubbing seals in the head?...greed…eh?

  • 04-18-10 By candy sheeran(usa)

 1 2 3 >  Last »

Submit a comment

Please enter the word you see in the image below: